best clay for clay earrings (12)

Best Clay for Clay Earrings: A Comprehensive Guide for 2024

Clay earrings have become a popular accessory in recent years, with many people opting for these lightweight and stylish pieces to complete their outfits. Clay earrings are not only fashionable, but they are also affordable and easy to make, which has led to a surge in DIY clay earring tutorials online.

If you are looking to create your own clay earrings, the first thing you need to consider is the type of clay you will use. There are many different types of clay available, each with its own unique properties and benefits. However, not all types of clay are suitable for making earrings.

When choosing the best clay for clay earrings, it is important to consider factors such as the weight of the clay, its durability, and its ability to hold its shape. Lightweight and durable clays are ideal for earrings, as they will not weigh down your earlobes and will last for a long time.

To help you choose the best clay for your clay earrings, we have tested and reviewed several popular types of clay. In the following sections, we will provide detailed information about each type of clay, including its properties, benefits, and drawbacks, to help you make an informed decision.

Best Clay for Clay Earrings

If you're a jewelry maker, you know that the type of clay you use can make all the difference in the final product. Clay earrings have been a popular trend lately, and for good reason - they're lightweight, versatile, and can be made in endless designs. But with so many different types of clay available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. That's why we've put together a list of the best clay for clay earrings. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned pro, these clays will help you create beautiful and long-lasting earrings that your customers will love.

Lucomb Polymer Clay Earring Making Kit

best clay for clay earrings

If you're looking for a comprehensive kit to make your own polymer clay earrings, the Lucomb Polymer Clay Earring Making Kit is a great option.

Pros

  • Everything you need to get started: This kit comes with a wide variety of tools and supplies, including a rainbow of polymer clay colors, stainless steel clay cutters, jewelry pliers, and more.
  • Personalized jewelry DIY: With all the different shapes and sizes of clay earring molds and cutters, you can create unique and beautiful jewelry pieces.
  • Fun kit, great gift idea: This kit is perfect for beginners and makes a great gift for anyone who loves DIY projects.

Cons

  • Clay can be a bit sticky: You may need to let the clay dry out a bit before using it, or dust the cutters with cornstarch to prevent sticking.
  • Small amounts of clay: While the kit does come with 24 different colors of clay, the amounts are relatively small.
  • Glue can be tricky: Some users have reported difficulty getting the glue to dry properly on the clay.

If you're looking to make your own polymer clay earrings, the Lucomb Polymer Clay Earring Making Kit has everything you need to get started. With a wide variety of tools and supplies, you can create personalized and unique jewelry pieces that are sure to impress. Just keep in mind that the clay can be a bit sticky, and you may need to let it dry out or dust the cutters with cornstarch to prevent sticking. Additionally, the amounts of clay are relatively small, so you may need to purchase additional clay if you plan to make a lot of earrings.

Polymer Clay Earrings Making Kit

best clay for clay earrings (1)

If you're a beginner looking to make clay earrings, the Polymer Clay Earrings Making Kit by Snoghmil is a great option.

Pros

  • Comes with 32 metal clay cutters in various shapes to create cute earring designs.
  • The 1.2lbs of 24 bright colors oven-baked clay is enough to make a number of earrings.
  • The kit provides all the necessary accessories for making 30 pieces of earrings, including hypoallergenic earring hooks and jump rings.

Cons

  • The clay may be too soft and difficult to mold for some users.
  • The kit lacks a roller, which may make it difficult to work with the clay.
  • Some users have reported issues with the clay not hardening properly after baking.

This kit is perfect for beginners, as it comes with all the necessary tools and a detailed manual. However, it may not be the best option for those with more experience working with clay. Overall, this kit is a great gift idea for birthdays, mother's day, valentine's day, halloween, christmas and more.

Keoker 10 Organic Shape Clay Earring Cutters

best clay for clay earrings (2)

If you're looking for a versatile set of clay cutters to create unique and eye-catching earrings, the Keoker 10 Organic Shape Clay Earring Cutters may be a good choice for you.

Pros

  • You can create a variety of shapes with the 10 different cutters included in the set.
  • The clear cutting design provides a smoother and more comfortable cutting experience.
  • The size of the cutters is perfect for making small clay earrings and studs that are popular among American women.

Cons

  • The product color is randomly shipped, so you may not receive the color you prefer.
  • You need to use cornstarch before use to prevent the clay from sticking inside the cutters.
  • The cutters may deform if washed in a dishwasher or exposed to high heat.

These polymer clay cutters are made by 3D printer with 0.4mm cutting edge, allowing for precise and clean cuts. The organic shapes of the cutters add an interesting touch to your clay earrings. The Keoker 10 Organic Shape Clay Earring Cutters are easy to use and clean, making them a great choice for beginners and experienced users alike.

In summary, if you're looking for a set of clay cutters to create unique and beautiful earrings, the Keoker 10 Organic Shape Clay Earring Cutters are a good option to consider.

Keoker Polymer Clay Texture Sheets

best clay for clay earrings (3)

If you're looking to elevate your polymer clay earring game, Keoker Polymer Clay Texture Sheets might just be the tool you need.

Pros

  • Create endless design possibilities with versatile texture molds
  • Add professional-looking details and textures to your polymer clay projects
  • Say goodbye to boring and plain polymer clay earrings

Cons

  • May require the use of cornstarch to prevent sticking
  • Texture mats are smaller than expected
  • Clay tends to stick if it's too warm

Keoker Polymer Clay Texture Sheets come with a set of rubber texture mats that are perfect for beginners and experienced polymer clay artists alike. Experiment with different designs and textures to create one-of-a-kind earrings that stand out from the crowd.

With a 4.5-star rating and 79 ratings total, customers are raving about the incredible detail and ease of use of these texture sheets. While some users suggest using cornstarch to prevent sticking, others recommend working with cooler clay to achieve the best results.

Overall, if you're looking to take your polymer clay earring game to the next level, Keoker Polymer Clay Texture Sheets are definitely worth considering.

Keoker Mini Petal Clay Cutters

best clay for clay earrings (4)

Looking for an easy and efficient way to make beautiful clay earrings? The Keoker Mini Petal Clay Cutters can help you create unique and intricate petal earrings with ease.

Pros

  • The 6 different shapes of the cutters allow for a variety of designs and styles.
  • The 0.3mm cutting edge of the cutters provides a smoother and more comfortable cutting experience.
  • The kit includes additional tools like metal ball tools, dotting pen tools, and a magic petal pad to make the process even easier.

Cons

  • There is a bit of a learning curve to using the cutters effectively.
  • The instructions are not included, so beginners may need to do some research before using.
  • The metal material may not be as durable as other options.

If you're looking for a high-quality clay cutter kit to make unique and beautiful jewelry, the Keoker Mini Petal Clay Cutters are a great choice. With their variety of shapes and additional tools, you'll be able to create a wide range of petal earrings with ease. Just be aware that there may be a bit of a learning curve and the metal material may not be as durable as other options.

Keoker Polymer Clay Cutters

best clay for clay earrings (5)

If you're looking for an affordable set of clay cutters to make unique polymer clay earrings, Keoker Polymer Clay Cutters might be a good fit for you.

Pros

  • The set includes ten different shapes of cutters, allowing you to create a variety of earring designs.
  • The clear cutting design and 0.4mm cutting edge provide a smooth and comfortable cutting experience.
  • The cutters are the correct size for small clay earrings and studs for American women.

Cons

  • The product color is randomly shipped, so you may receive pink or white cutters.
  • You need to use cornstarch before use to prevent the clay from sticking inside the cutters.
  • Dishwasher and high heat may deform the shape, so you need to hand wash or wipe with alcohol.

Keoker Polymer Clay Cutters are easy to use and can help you create unique and eye-catching earrings. The clear cutting design and 0.4mm cutting edge provide a smooth and comfortable cutting experience. The set includes ten different shapes of cutters, allowing you to create a variety of earring designs. However, the product color is randomly shipped, so you may receive pink or white cutters. You need to use cornstarch before use to prevent the clay from sticking inside the cutters, and you should hand wash or wipe with alcohol to avoid deformation from high heat or the dishwasher. Overall, if you're looking for an affordable set of clay cutters to make unique polymer clay earrings, Keoker Polymer Clay Cutters might be a good fit for you.

KEOKER Polymer Clay Texture Sheets, Clay Texture Mat for Making Earrings Jewerly, Polymer Clay Earrings Tools (A+B+C)

best clay for clay earrings (6)

If you are looking for an easy and efficient way to create professional-looking clay earrings, KEOKER Polymer Clay Texture Sheets are a great option.

Pros

  • The texture sheets are easy to use and produce professional results every time.
  • The flower texture mat is perfect for making vintage floral jewelry with polymer clay cutters.
  • The texture sheets can get a smooth, even surface every time.

Cons

  • The textures aren't deep, but are deep enough to provide subtle texture.
  • If you do not follow the operating steps, cleaning may be required.
  • The matjes were smaller than expected.

KEOKER Polymer Clay Texture Sheets are an essential tool for any clay artist. They allow you to create textured surfaces on your clay pieces, enhancing their visual appeal. The creative possibilities are endless. The texture sheets are easy to use and produce professional results every time. The flower texture mat is perfect for making vintage floral jewelry with polymer clay cutters. Compared to a polymer clay roller, texture sheets for polymer clay can get a smooth, even surface every time.

If you are looking for a product that will help you create beautiful and unique clay earrings, KEOKER Polymer Clay Texture Sheets are a great option. With their easy-to-use design and professional results, they are perfect for both beginners and experienced clay artists.

JOiFULi 132 Pc- Complete DIY Friendship Craft Set for Teens, Ages 12+ Aesthetic Polymer Clay Earring Jewelry Craft Making Set

best clay for clay earrings (7)

If you're looking for a complete set to create beautiful polymer clay earrings, then the JOiFULi 132 Pc- Complete DIY Friendship Craft Set is a great option to consider.

Pros

  • Comes with everything you need to get started
  • High-quality materials for professional results
  • Easy-to-follow instructions for beginners

Cons

  • Some users found the clay hard to work with
  • The roller may get clay stuck to it
  • Takes longer than 15 minutes to bake the pieces

This set includes 14 clay blocks, 6 metal clay cutters, 1 roller, 1 texture tool, 2 wooden craft sticks, 1 pair of jewelry pliers, 6 pairs of brass charms, 50 jump rings, 50 earring hooks, and 1 medium grit sandpaper. With this comprehensive guide, you'll master three stunning techniques - Terrazzo, Color Blocking, and Marbling - to create a diverse collection of earrings that suit every occasion.

Crafting isn't just about making jewelry; it's about self-expression and self-discovery. The JOiFULi kit provides the canvas for you to express yourself and let your creativity shine. It's perfect for gifting too - create stunning earrings for your loved ones, tailor-made to match their style.

While some users found the clay hard to work with, the high-quality materials included in this set ensure your creations are of professional quality. The easy-to-follow instructions ensure that even beginners can create beautiful earrings. Just keep in mind that it may take longer than 15 minutes to bake the pieces.

Overall, the JOiFULi 132 Pc- Complete DIY Friendship Craft Set is a great option for anyone looking to create beautiful polymer clay earrings. With everything you need to get started and easy-to-follow instructions, you'll be able to unleash your inner artist and create stunning pieces of jewelry.

Shuttle Art 82 Colors Polymer Clay Kit

best clay for clay earrings (8)

If you're looking for a complete polymer clay kit that is safe for children and beginners, then Shuttle Art 82 Colors Polymer Clay Kit is worth considering.

Pros

  • The kit includes 82 colors of oven-bake clay, 19 polymer clay tools, and 16 kinds of accessories to create small ornaments, model animals, characters, and more.
  • The clay is non-toxic, non-fragrance, and strictly conforms to ASTM D-4236, ASTM F2923-20 & EN71 Standards and Requirements.
  • The kit comes with a fancy box, making it an ideal gift for Christmas, birthdays, and other festivals.

Cons

  • The clay may not harden well after baking, and it may not soften much before baking for sculpting.
  • The bars of clay are smaller than standard Fimo blocks, which may not be enough for larger projects.
  • The plastic carrier may be prone to breaking during shipping.

Shuttle Art 82 Colors Polymer Clay Kit is an excellent choice for those who want a complete and safe polymer clay kit for small projects. The kit includes a wide variety of colors, tools, and accessories that can unleash your creativity. However, the clay may not harden well after baking, and the bars of clay are smaller than standard Fimo blocks. Overall, if you're looking for a versatile and safe polymer clay kit, Shuttle Art 82 Colors Polymer Clay Kit is worth considering.

Arteza Polymer Clay Kit

best clay for clay earrings (9)

Looking for a versatile and vibrant polymer clay kit for your next DIY project? The Arteza Polymer Clay Kit may be just what you need.

Pros

  • Enjoy a wide range of 42 vibrant clay bars that retain their colors after baking.
  • Easy to mold or sculpt, and won't stain your hands.
  • Comes with 5 sculpting tools to help you create unique shapes and designs.

Cons

  • The clay can become too soft, making it difficult to handle.
  • Some users reported that the box and tools were not as sturdy as they expected.
  • Compared to other brands, this kit may be a bit pricey.

If you're looking for a polymer clay kit that offers a variety of colors and tools, the Arteza Polymer Clay Kit is a great choice. With 42 vibrant clay bars to choose from, you can mix and match colors to create unique swirls and shades. The clay is soft and pliable, making it easy to mold or sculpt without staining your hands.

The kit comes with 5 sculpting tools that are perfect for creating intricate details and shapes. Whether you're making clay earrings, jewelry, or other crafts, this kit has everything you need to get started.

However, some users reported that the clay can become too soft, which can make it difficult to handle. Additionally, some users found that the box and tools were not as sturdy as they expected. Finally, compared to other brands, this kit may be a bit pricey.

Overall, the Arteza Polymer Clay Kit is a great choice for anyone looking for a versatile and vibrant polymer clay kit. With its wide range of colors and sculpting tools, you'll have everything you need to create unique and beautiful crafts.

Caydo Polymer Clay Earring Making Kit

best clay for clay earrings (10)

If you're looking for a beginner-friendly polymer clay earring making kit, the Caydo Polymer Clay Earring Making Kit is a great option.

Pros

  • The kit comes with a 3-layer storage box, 30 clay earring cutters, 24 colors of clay, 8 circle cutters, clay tools, and earring accessories, making it a complete package for earring making.
  • The polymer clay is non-toxic and has good toughness, making it safe to use and easy to shape.
  • The kit is a great Christmas gift for craft lovers.

Cons

  • The plastic storage box is lightweight but not very sturdy.
  • The clay can be too sticky and hard to work with for some users.
  • The roller is a small tube, not a solid acrylic roller.

This kit is great for beginners as it comes with everything you need to start making clay earrings. The polymer clay is non-toxic and easy to shape, and the kit includes detailed instructions to help you get started. The storage box is convenient for organizing your materials, but it may not be very durable. The clay can be sticky and difficult to work with, but with practice, you can create beautiful and unique earrings. Overall, the Caydo Polymer Clay Earring Making Kit is a practical and affordable option for those looking to start making clay earrings.

Caydo Polymer Clay Earring Kit

best clay for clay earrings (11)

If you're looking for a complete polymer clay earring kit, the Caydo Polymer Clay Earring Kit might be the perfect choice for you.

Pros

  • The kit includes 44 different colors of polymer clay, 24 polymer clay earring cutters, 8 circle shape cutters, 90 earring accessories, 3 clay tools, 3 earring texture roller, an acrylic hollow roller, an acrylic sheet, plier, lettering stamp and instructions, which makes it a complete kit for earring making.
  • The three-layer storage box is made of high-quality plastic, lightweight, strong, resistant to dirt, and not easy to crack, which will be more convenient for you to store and organize after completing this excellent activity with your kids and friends.
  • With 44 colors of clay, plenty of molds, different shapes and styles, and a sufficient amount of earring hooks, you can design your style of earrings, key rings, rings, and necklaces. Even if you're a beginner, you can easily operate under the guidance of the instructions.

Cons

  • The amount of clay for each color is small, so you might want to buy extra clay if you're planning on making many earrings.
  • Some users reported that the clay never hardened, even after baking, which might be a concern if you prefer a more rigid clay.
  • Some of the tools are not of the best quality, and some of the cutters are not suitable for earring making.

This polymer clay earring kit is an excellent choice for anyone who wants to start making earrings and other jewelry. The kit includes everything you need to get started, and the instructions are easy to follow. With 44 different colors of clay, you can experiment and create unique designs. However, the amount of clay for each color is small, and some of the tools are not of the best quality. Overall, the Caydo Polymer Clay Earring Kit is a great gift for family, friends, and polymer clay earrings lovers.

Keoker Clay Earring Making Kit

If you want to try your hand at making polymer clay earrings, the Keoker Clay Earring Making Kit is a great option for beginners.

Pros

  • The kit includes all the basic tools and materials you need to make polymer clay earrings.
  • The polymer clay is of premium quality and comes in five basic colors that can be mixed to create almost any color.
  • The step-by-step design guide video makes it easy for beginners to create beautiful earrings.

Cons

  • Some users have reported that the clay doesn't harden properly even after baking.
  • The kit may not be suitable for experienced polymer clay artists who already have their own tools and materials.
  • The kit only includes basic colors, so you may need to purchase additional colors if you want to create more intricate designs.

The Keoker Clay Earring Making Kit is a great gift for anyone who loves DIY projects and jewelry making. The kit contains 23 polymer clay cutters, a depth guide, a tissue blade, a silk screen for polymer clay, and five basic colors of professional polymer clay. The full-color recipe included in the kit makes it easy to mix colors and create beautiful earrings.

The step-by-step design guide video included in the kit is beginner-friendly and easy to follow. Even if you have no prior experience with polymer clay, you can create beautiful earrings with this kit. The tools included in the kit are of professional quality and can be used for other polymer clay projects as well.

However, some users have reported that the clay doesn't harden properly even after baking. This may be due to differences in baking times and temperatures, or variations in the quality of the clay. If you experience this issue, you may need to experiment with different baking times and temperatures or try a different brand of polymer clay.

Overall, the Keoker Clay Earring Making Kit is a great choice for beginners who want to try their hand at making polymer clay earrings. The kit includes all the basic tools and materials you need to get started, and the step-by-step design guide video makes it easy to create beautiful earrings.

Buying Guide

When shopping for clay for your earrings, there are a few things you should consider to ensure you get the best product. Here are some factors to keep in mind:

Type of Clay

There are different types of clay available, and each has its own unique properties. For example, polymer clay is known for its flexibility and durability, while air-dry clay is more brittle but dries faster. Choose the type of clay that best fits your needs and preferences.

Color

Clay comes in a wide range of colors, so consider the color of your earrings when choosing your clay. Some clays can be mixed to create custom colors, while others come pre-colored.

Texture

The texture of your clay will affect the final look of your earrings. Some clays are smooth, while others have a more rustic or textured finish. Consider the style of your earrings and the look you want to achieve when choosing your clay.

Hardness

The hardness of your clay will affect how easy it is to work with and shape. Some clays are softer and more pliable, while others are harder and require more effort to mold. Consider your skill level and the intricacy of your design when choosing your clay.

Price

Clay can vary in price depending on the type, brand, and quantity. Consider your budget when choosing your clay, but also keep in mind that a higher price doesn't always guarantee a better product.

By considering these factors, you can ensure that you choose the best clay for your clay earrings.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top types of clay recommended for making earrings?

The best types of clay for making earrings are polymer clay, air-dry clay, and oven-bake clay. Polymer clay is a popular choice due to its versatility, durability, and wide range of colors. Air-dry clay is a great option for those who prefer natural materials and want to avoid using an oven. Oven-bake clay is perfect for those who want a more durable finish and faster drying time.

Which polymer clay brand is preferred for durable earring designs?

Brands like Fimo, Sculpey, and Kato Polyclay are known for their durability and strength. These brands offer a range of colors and textures to choose from, making them a popular choice for earring making.

For beginners, which clay is easiest to handle when crafting earrings?

Sculpey III and Fimo Soft are both great options for beginners. They are easy to handle, have a smooth texture, and come in a variety of colors. They are also affordable, making them a great choice for those who are just starting out.

What qualities should I look for in clay when making jewelry, specifically earrings?

When making earrings, it's important to choose a clay that is lightweight, durable, and easy to mold. The clay should also be able to hold its shape and not crack or break easily. Additionally, the clay should be hypoallergenic and safe for sensitive skin.

How does Sculpey clay perform for earring creation compared to other brands?

Sculpey clay is a great choice for earring making due to its smooth texture, easy handling, and durability. It also comes in a variety of colors and can be used for a range of techniques, including caning, sculpting, and molding.

What are the best practices for molding clay to ensure high-quality earrings?

To ensure high-quality earrings, it's important to properly condition the clay before molding. This involves kneading the clay until it is soft and pliable. It's also important to use clean tools and work surfaces to prevent contamination. Additionally, it's important to bake the earrings at the correct temperature and time to prevent cracking or burning.

Back to blog
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

About Author

Mantas, DRIPCRIME Designer

Mantas is a professional merch graphic designer with years of expierence in alternative, y2k, goth grunge, punk industry. The passion for the industry has lead Mantas to become one of main designers and writers at DRIPCRIME store.